How Modern Confessions Build on the Ancient Creeds

Rev. C•D•F• Warrington, M.Div.
By Rev. C•D•F• Warrington, M.Div.

Ordained Minister, M.Div.

April 10, 2026

2 min read

Oil painting of ancient creedal manuscripts forming the theological foundation on which modern confessions are built in golden light

When Barth drafted the Barmen Declaration, he was not writing a new creed. He was applying the ancient confession of Christ as Lord to the specific situation of the German church in 1934. When the Lausanne Covenant was written, it assumed and built on the Trinitarian and Christological foundations of the ancient creeds. Modern confessions do not replace the classical tradition — they stand on it and extend it into new contexts.

The Classic-Modern Relationship

The Apostles' and Nicene Creeds define the doctrinal core that any legitimate confession must affirm: the Triune God, the full divinity and humanity of Christ, the resurrection, the church, the coming judgment. A modern confession that contradicted any of these would not be a confession of the Christian faith at all. Legitimate modern confessions add to this core by addressing questions the ancient creeds did not — questions about Scripture's authority, the relationship of evangelism to social action, or the church’s response to political totalitarianism.

Continuity as Faithfulness

This continuity is not intellectual conservatism — it is faithfulness. The God confessed in the ancient creeds is the same God addressed by the modern confessions. The gospel summarized in the creeds is the same gospel the Lausanne Covenant commits to proclaiming to every people. The confession of Christ as Lord that opens every creed is precisely what the Barmen Declaration insists cannot be compromised by political ideology. Modern and ancient are not in tension; they are a tradition.

A Christian who knows both the Nicene Creed and the Barmen Declaration, both the Westminster Confession and the Lausanne Covenant, is equipped with a theological breadth that spans fifteen centuries of the church confessing its faith under diverse pressures. That is a rich inheritance — and a living tradition that is still being written.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do modern confessions relate to the ancient creeds?

Modern confessions typically presuppose and affirm the ancient ecumenical creeds — the Apostles', Nicene, and Athanasian — and build on them by addressing questions the creeds left open. They go deeper on issues like Scripture's authority, the nature of salvation, the sacraments, and church governance.

Do modern confessions replace the ancient creeds?

No — they extend them. The ancient creeds define the universal Christian baseline on the Trinity and the Incarnation. Modern confessions address the contested questions within that baseline. A well-written modern confession would not contradict the Nicene Creed but would assume it.

What is an example of a modern confession that engages with the ancient creeds?

The Barmen Declaration (1934) quotes the Apostles' Creed and grounds its resistance to Nazi ideology in the ancient confession of Christ as Lord. The Unity Creed similarly draws on creedal language while speaking to contemporary needs for unity among Christians.

Can the church still write confessions today?

Yes — the church in every age faces new challenges that require fresh articulation of the faith. While no new confession can add to Scripture or overrule the ancient ecumenical creeds, confessional writing remains a vital act of the church's ongoing theological discernment and witness.